CAMB vs CLASS Fisher-matrix validation for arXiv:2303.09451v1 (baseline-model MontePython validation) and arXiv:2405.06047v1 (sensitivity to the neutrino sector). Click a row for the full per-parameter breakdown and the exact YAML/spec files used.
| Case | Model | Probe | Scenario | Variant | Max deviation | Gate | State |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| arXiv:2303.09451v1 - baseline-model MontePython validation | |||||||
| 01.1.0 | w0waCDM | Spectro | Pessimistic | P_mm | 0.35% (Omegab) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 01.1.1 | w0waCDM | Spectro | Optimistic | P_mm | 0.37% (Omegam) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 01.2.0 | w0waCDM | Photo | Pessimistic | P_mm | 0.76% (Omegab) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 01.2.1 | w0waCDM | Photo | Optimistic | P_mm | 0.93% (Omegab) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| arXiv:2405.06047v1 - sensitivity to the neutrino sector | |||||||
| 02.1.0 | w0waCDM | Spectro | Pessimistic | P_cb | 0.59% (Ps_1) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 02.1.1 | w0waCDM | Spectro | Optimistic | P_cb | 0.57% (Ps_1) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 02.2.0 | w0waCDM | Photo | Pessimistic | P_cb | 0.86% (Omegab) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 02.2.1 | w0waCDM | Photo | Optimistic | P_cb | 1.14% (Omegab) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 03.1.0 | LCDM + mnu, Neff | Spectro | Pessimistic | P_cb | 1.25% (Ps_1) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 03.1.1 | LCDM + mnu, Neff | Spectro | Optimistic | P_cb | 1.02% (h) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 03.2.0 | LCDM + mnu, Neff | Photo | Pessimistic | P_cb | 5.53% (mnu) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 03.2.1 | LCDM + mnu, Neff | Photo | Optimistic | P_cb | 2.60% (b10) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 04.1.0 | w0CDM + mnu | Spectro | Pessimistic | P_cb | 1.12% (Ps_1) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 04.1.1 | w0CDM + mnu | Spectro | Optimistic | P_cb | 0.74% (h) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 04.2.0 | w0CDM + mnu | Photo | Pessimistic | P_cb | 5.49% (mnu) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 04.2.1 | w0CDM + mnu | Photo | Optimistic | P_cb | 1.98% (mnu) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| Beyond paper validation | |||||||
| 05.1.0 | LCDM | Spectro | Pessimistic | P_cb | 1.33% (sigma8) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 05.2.0 | LCDM | Photo | Pessimistic | P_cb | 1.17% (Omegab) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 06.1.0 | LCDM + mnu | Spectro | Pessimistic | P_cb | 1.17% (Ps_1) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 06.2.0 | LCDM + mnu | Photo | Pessimistic | P_cb | 4.24% (mnu) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 07.1.0 | w0waCDM + mnu | Spectro | Pessimistic | P_cb | 1.29% (Ps_2) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 07.2.0 | w0waCDM + mnu | Photo | Pessimistic | P_cb | 6.34% (mnu) | PASS | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 07.2.0.1 | w0waCDM + mnu | Photo | Pessimistic | P_mm | 14.70% (mnu) | FAIL | 0462bd8 (dirty) |
| 08.1.0 | w0waCDM + mnu, Neff | Spectro | Pessimistic | P_cb | 2.32% (ns) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |
| 08.2.0 | w0waCDM + mnu, Neff | Photo | Pessimistic | P_cb | 5.10% (mnu) | PASS | b0e8eb1 (dirty) |